Toronto Employment Lawyer Brian Bell - Regarding the alcohol testing case currently headed for the Supreme Court, this type of thing has been an issue for years. I recall cases within the financial industry where institutions wanted to test employees for substance abuse, and ultimately the action was thrown out - primarily because of the answer to one question: is the testing necessary for the job (i.e. safety concerns)?
If the answer to that question is yes, then the next issue is whether the company’s testing program is too invasive. Ultimately, a blanket yes to testing has the potential for a very slippery slope.
In the current testing case, the company’s position is that testing is necessary for safety reasons, and given this article's content, I would agree.
I would also agree with the unions who say such a policy is not required where it infringes excessively on the rights of the workers. An additional valid point is whether there has to be an “incident” before an employer can introduce such a policy to protect other workers as well as themselves.
It remains unclear where the line should be drawn, and the Supreme Court will have to determine whether a line needs to be drawn at all. I'm looking forward to the outcome of the case.
Pace Law Firm. 1-416-236-3060. Our labour and employment practice involves giving organizations and individuals cost effective advice on a broad range of labour and employment law issues. We fight for our clients' rights. Note that this page is not direct legal advice and may not apply to your situation. Consult a professional before making legal decisions.
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Monday, May 14, 2012
Wednesday, May 9, 2012
Should Random Alcohol Tests Be Allowed in the Workplace?
![]() |
| Testing? |
It’s a fight that began with one pulp-and-paper mill worker in Saint John, and a “zero” reading on a breath-analysis alcohol test six years ago. Now, it is headed to Canada’s highest court.
The case, which pits the Communications Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada Local 30 against Irving Pulp & Paper Ltd., is being watched closely by employment lawyers across Canada, who say it could have broad implications.Read the rest of the story here.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

